Respectfully they are subjective so I expect people to disagree. However:
The community is a huge part of judging a language. You'll note that I specifically said this appears to flow from the core developers out. A sentiment many in this thread appear to have shared. That to me is a danger sign. The community often is a signal regarding how the core devs of the language approach things.
As for beauty it's completely and purely subjective so what looks beautiful to one person can look ugly to another.
The community is a huge part of judging a language. You'll note that I specifically said this appears to flow from the core developers out. A sentiment many in this thread appear to have shared. That to me is a danger sign. The community often is a signal regarding how the core devs of the language approach things.
As for beauty it's completely and purely subjective so what looks beautiful to one person can look ugly to another.