Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Citation? I don't see anything in the announcement that indicates this is being driven by "US morality".

Right, 'cause Apple (presumably; otherwise this restriction would apply to Android and desktop as well) imposes such rules for gits and shiggles.

Those of us living in the United States and subjected to the inconsistently-applied puritanical moral code that permeates throughout it witness and experience said permeation daily. You want a citation? The article's a citation; it's literally an American company imposing this restriction. Tumblr banning "pornographic" content entirely is a citation. Google making it literally impossible to disable SafeSearch is a citation. The continued existence of rules around profanity on TV and radio is a citation.

> What about it? They're a private company who may choose to not be associated with that content.

I think the point of that remark is that Discord does currently allow "servers full of war scenes and car chasing with shootings", and hardly anyone bats an eye at this, yet the moment anyone shows so much as a boob it's suddenly an outrage.



add reddit recently removing "sexually explicit content" (but not violence and gore) from /r/all to your list of citations (https://www.reddit.com/r/changelog/comments/lhnvok/removing_...)


> "They're a private company"

Private companies seem to have more rights and less responsebilities than people these days, can I incorporate myself?


>Those of us living in the United States and subjected to the inconsistently-applied puritanical moral code that permeates throughout it witness and experience said permeation daily.

So it's puritanical code. The same code that believes homosexuality is a sin. And you think the gay CEO of Apple is basing his decisions on that code. But there's no record of him saying or doing so and it logically makes absolutely no sense.

>I think the point of that remark is that Discord does currently allow "servers full of war scenes and car chasing with shootings", and hardly anyone bats an eye at this, yet the moment anyone shows so much as a boob it's suddenly an outrage.

And those servers are 18+... and banned from the iOS platform, and are part of this announcement. So I still am not following the logic.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: